Human factors in maintenance

LibraryMAE-HF-01 · Rev. 1 · November 2026

Human factors in maintenance

The Dirty Dozen and the main models used to analyse maintenance error

The “Dirty Dozen” are the twelve most common maintenance-related causes of human error identified by the FAA in its maintenance human factors guidance. The safeguards listed are typical examples of the counter-measures promoted in FAA safety material, not an exhaustive list.

The Dirty Dozen

FactorWhat it meansTypical safeguards
Lack of communicationInformation not passed, or passed incompletely, between people, shifts or departmentsWritten handovers; read-back of critical information
ComplacencyOverconfidence from repetition, leading to reduced vigilanceExpect to find a fault; never sign for work not seen
Lack of knowledgeWorking without the training, experience or current data the task needsUse current approved data; ask a qualified person
DistractionAn interruption that breaks the sequence of a taskMark the point reached; restart a few steps back
Lack of teamworkPoor co-ordination and shared understanding within a teamAgree goals and responsibilities; brief and debrief
FatiguePhysical or mental tiredness that degrades judgement and performanceRecognise symptoms; plan rest; independent checks on critical tasks
Lack of resourcesMissing tools, parts, data or people needed to do the job properlyCheck resources before starting; report shortfalls
PressureReal or perceived time pressure that pushes towards shortcutsCommunicate concerns; do not let deadlines set the standard
Lack of assertivenessNot speaking up when something is wrongState facts and concerns clearly; refuse to compromise standards
StressA reaction to demands that exceed what a person can cope withRecognise the signs; take a break; talk it through
Lack of awarenessFailing to recognise the consequences of an actionAsk “what if?”; check the work of others
NormsUnwritten local practices that differ from the approved procedureFollow the approved procedure; challenge unsafe norms

Models used to analyse error

ModelIdeaOrigin
SHELLPlaces the person (Liveware) at the centre and examines the interfaces with Software (procedures, documents), Hardware (tools, equipment), Environment and other Liveware (people).Edwards (1972), Hawkins (1975)
Swiss cheeseAccidents result when weaknesses in several defensive layers line up; distinguishes active failures from latent conditions in the organisation.Reason (1990, 1997)
PEARPeople, Environment, Actions and Resources: a structure for maintenance human factors programmes.Johnson and Maddox (2007)

Sources

  1. Federal Aviation Administration, Advisory Circular AC 120-72A, Maintenance Human Factors Training, 2017.
  2. Federal Aviation Administration, Aviation Maintenance Technician Handbook — General, FAA-H-8083-30B, 2023, Chapter 14 Human Factors.
  3. FAA Safety Team, Avoid the Dirty Dozen, safety leaflet, faa.gov.
  4. Hawkins, F. H., Human Factors in Flight, 2nd ed., Ashgate, 1993.
  5. Reason, J., Managing the Risks of Organizational Accidents, Ashgate, 1997.

Study material only. Not approved maintenance or operational data; always use the current approved documentation.

Mr Aircraft Engineer — open aviation and aerospace education.Study material only; not approved maintenance data.About · Contact · Privacy · Terms