LibraryMAE-HF-01 · Rev. 1 · November 2026
Human factors in maintenance
The Dirty Dozen and the main models used to analyse maintenance error
The “Dirty Dozen” are the twelve most common maintenance-related causes of human error identified by the FAA in its maintenance human factors guidance. The safeguards listed are typical examples of the counter-measures promoted in FAA safety material, not an exhaustive list.
The Dirty Dozen
| Factor | What it means | Typical safeguards |
|---|---|---|
| Lack of communication | Information not passed, or passed incompletely, between people, shifts or departments | Written handovers; read-back of critical information |
| Complacency | Overconfidence from repetition, leading to reduced vigilance | Expect to find a fault; never sign for work not seen |
| Lack of knowledge | Working without the training, experience or current data the task needs | Use current approved data; ask a qualified person |
| Distraction | An interruption that breaks the sequence of a task | Mark the point reached; restart a few steps back |
| Lack of teamwork | Poor co-ordination and shared understanding within a team | Agree goals and responsibilities; brief and debrief |
| Fatigue | Physical or mental tiredness that degrades judgement and performance | Recognise symptoms; plan rest; independent checks on critical tasks |
| Lack of resources | Missing tools, parts, data or people needed to do the job properly | Check resources before starting; report shortfalls |
| Pressure | Real or perceived time pressure that pushes towards shortcuts | Communicate concerns; do not let deadlines set the standard |
| Lack of assertiveness | Not speaking up when something is wrong | State facts and concerns clearly; refuse to compromise standards |
| Stress | A reaction to demands that exceed what a person can cope with | Recognise the signs; take a break; talk it through |
| Lack of awareness | Failing to recognise the consequences of an action | Ask “what if?”; check the work of others |
| Norms | Unwritten local practices that differ from the approved procedure | Follow the approved procedure; challenge unsafe norms |
Models used to analyse error
| Model | Idea | Origin |
|---|---|---|
| SHELL | Places the person (Liveware) at the centre and examines the interfaces with Software (procedures, documents), Hardware (tools, equipment), Environment and other Liveware (people). | Edwards (1972), Hawkins (1975) |
| Swiss cheese | Accidents result when weaknesses in several defensive layers line up; distinguishes active failures from latent conditions in the organisation. | Reason (1990, 1997) |
| PEAR | People, Environment, Actions and Resources: a structure for maintenance human factors programmes. | Johnson and Maddox (2007) |
Sources
- Federal Aviation Administration, Advisory Circular AC 120-72A, Maintenance Human Factors Training, 2017.
- Federal Aviation Administration, Aviation Maintenance Technician Handbook — General, FAA-H-8083-30B, 2023, Chapter 14 Human Factors.
- FAA Safety Team, Avoid the Dirty Dozen, safety leaflet, faa.gov.
- Hawkins, F. H., Human Factors in Flight, 2nd ed., Ashgate, 1993.
- Reason, J., Managing the Risks of Organizational Accidents, Ashgate, 1997.
Study material only. Not approved maintenance or operational data; always use the current approved documentation.